I know a friend who loves MAC fluidline and I think her eyes look gorgeous.
I think the key to this liner is having a GOOD brush. I can't emphasize this enough because I currently don't have a good brush for it and it's making this liner very difficult to use. When I use liquid liner, I can do my liner in a couple minutes with the brush it comes with. But it takes me around 10 mins with this gel liner because I don't have a good brush! Don't use a cheap one off Ebay. I didn't like Sigma's angled brush because I found the brushes split too easy and I couldn't make a fine line (not sure if it's evident in the pictures below). I use my old liquid liner brush but I also find that awkward. I'm thinking of trying EcoTools or maybe suck it up and buy the MAC one.
What I have concluded/learned about this liner:
- It's a rich black pigmented formula
- Keep the lid on tight to prevent it from drying out
- I would say use a primer underneath because if you have oily lids (like me), it smudges terribly by the end of the day
- it works amazing with tears. I was wearing it while watching something sad on tv and despite crying, my eyeliner did not budge. If I ever get married, I will be wearing this liner on my wedding day!
Verdict: *Thumbs up*